Confessions of a Fake Reviewer

money changing handsI got paid for reviews. Did you know that? Yeah, me neither. You can imagine my surprise when a friend of mine directed me to a site listing myself amongst other people that were guilty of writing fake reviews.

I was outraged, I was upset, I was distraught! Here I could have been making money with the reviews I’ve written! Or at the very least I could have had the authors I’ve reviewed do something beneficial for me… what? I don’t know, but if I had time to think about it I’m sure we could’ve have worked out something. Maybe a trade of cookies for good reviews. Or ice cream, or… (gasp) do you think I could have had someone send me pumpkin pie for my reviews?!

Why didn’t anyone tell me I was supposed to be writing fake reviews?

See, I was naive to the whole indie publishing trade, and little wide-eyed innocent me thought I would help those braving the publishing world on their own by reading their book and, if I liked it, reviewing it.  I had no idea that by running a site introducing self published authors to my followers that I was doing fraudulent work. Here I thought I was doing good by reviewing a book I liked, having the author interviewed on my site and having the writer post a guest blog to compliment the interview.insert cookies

Now I find out that I could have not only gotten paid for the time I put in but I didn’t even have to read the book!! Think of what I could have been doing that time instead of writing reviews. I could have been eating the mountain of cookies authors sent me in return for a good review.

All joking aside, this blogger has made some serious accusations. Authors that have become my friends over time are called into question and it’s disturbing.

However, for me, it’s not the accusations that bother me, but it’s the cowardice in which these posts were created. There is no proof, no credible line of evidence and worse of all, there is no name.

I was raised that if you can’t put your name on an opinion don’t have one. There is no way to directly question the author of the two posts in which my name is listed, no way for me to defend my name and my ethics. And that pisses me off to no end.

The material is posted on a WordPress site, and according to WordPress my only course of action is to report the content, which I did, and respond on my own space, which is why you’re reading this.

I’m not posting the link to the posts because I chose not to. I’m sure if you do your research you’ll find it but I hope you wouldn’t because I believe a big part of this controversy is just to cause trouble and I would like to think my supporters wouldn’t want to perpetuate that. The purpose of this specific post is to put the truth out there on my behalf, I can not speak for the other reviewers and authors on that list. I just needed to say my peace and be done with it.

For your reading pleasure, here is a quick background into my reviewing history:

WOTR

Several years ago a friend and I decided to start a site, Writing on the Rocks, to interview and review Independent authors. Our goal was to pair up reviewers of a genre with a writer of the same genre. One author contacted us and said they’d review a book if only the author of that book would review theirs. We declined their offer and due to a lack of interested reviewers we suspended the site.

My friend and I decided to concentrate on our own individual sites. I continued to review books I enjoyed, interviewed the authors and gave them a spot on my blog for a guest post. I would also list my review on Amazon, Barnes and Noble and any other site the author listed their book.

Apparently this practice was a part of a fake review process.

I did this routine for several months until I grew bored and burned out and I wanted to focus on other areas of my life.

So that’s it. My whole, sordid story of a fake reviewer. A fake reviewer who didn’t receive compensation, cookies or otherwise, who wasn’t sought out to provide only positive reviews; a fake reviewer who used her real name in posting her reviews, and who didn’t have a book, or any other reviewable work, at the time to give a glowing review in trade for a glowing review of my own.

I’m a rebel, I tell ya. Someone should watch out for me. I review books I like and tell the world I like them. OH THE HUMANITY! SOMEONE THINK OF THE CHILDREN!

The children. Whoops, I have children and soon one of them is going to get off the bus. I must draw this to a close so I can go be a mother to her and my youngest.

I’m hoping this is the only time I have to address this situation.

I wish you all the best and please, before you go spreading accusations have the decency to put your name on it and own it. Be a big boy or girl, people, and do good in the world.

bruce lee

** I always welcome comments, I make it a point to thank each commenter and respond. However, since I don’t see the need, nor do I have the desire, to continue discussion on this situation I will welcome comments but not respond. I will monitor the comments, so know that if you leave your support it will be seen and greatly appreciated. In turn, any disrespectful or rude comments will be deleted. Play nice with each other and remember at the end of the day we’re all just trying to survive and thrive. Help, don’t hurt, each other. **

 

 

 

9 Responses to “Confessions of a Fake Reviewer”

  1. Richard Allen Says:

    Feels like this sort of bullying is becoming the norm for indie writers. There are a bunch of hateful people out there trolling authors and some legitimate reviewers just because they are doing what they love. Some people have no lives. I am sure someone will eventually target me (again), but I don’t let it get to me. I know who I am and if someone starts trolling me with accusations it means I must be doing something right. Do what you do. Sincere reviews are always appreciated. I am sure the authors are thankful you take the time to give them feedback.

  2. Robert "Sharky" Pruneda Says:

    I heard about this a while back and it’s probably the same site you’re talking about. The accusations are completely unfounded and people need to understand that indie authors are also readers first. We all love to read and write and if we like a book that another indie author wrote what is the crime of leaving an honest good review. Haters will be haters and there are plenty of them out there in the world. I have heard of Amazon deleting reviews because they were from one author reviewing another author. Of course, I have reviewed other author’s books (ranging from 3 to 5 stars) and have yet to see anything removed. So, I have no idea what the criteria is. The way I see it, if I’m an Amazon customer and I purchase a book on their site I should have the right to review that book whether I’m an author or not. We can probably thank John Locke’s paid review scandal for this mess.

  3. Kimberly Gould Says:

    How horrible! Sadly I’m among those so desperate for reviews I would consider paying for them. sigh I hope the person in question realizes his mistake and feels remorse. If not, he deserves all that karma can deliver.

  4. Bill Olander Says:

    I found the web page today while doing a google search to see if you had a Goodreads account. I find it rather fascinating that the assumption seems to be that if a reviewer interacts with an author via social media then they are a ‘fake reviewer’. But my understanding was that part of the reason to go on social media as an author was to meet people and introduce them to your work. It just seems like these people lack understanding of how self-promotion works because they’re too hung up on the idea of the ‘purity’ of the craft.

  5. ppi Says:

    hello!,I really like your writing very much! share we keep up a correspondence extra approximately your post on AOL? I require an expert in this area to solve my problem. Maybe that is you! Looking ahead to see you.

  6. Kimberly Says:
    1. Engage your community with affiliate marketing on youtube (Kimberly): Audiences are about 10 times more prone to engage, embed, share, and discuss video content than blog sites or associated social articles.
  7. the four agreements pdf Says:

    One senses that the music spill out of all people, though her teenage rebellion the four agreements pdf is more prone to dissociative seizures.

  8. Leon Carland Says:

    Hey, regarding Clickbank – are there any recommendations about improving sales on a varied site? I have a image sharing site and as such it is very to match offers to the visitor. Many thanks

  9. code triche saint row 4 third Says:

    Great web site you have got here.. It’s hard to find quality writing like yours nowadays. I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

Leave a Reply